Connect with us

BUSINESS

Why compliance is the opposite of engagement

Chris Barrington

By Chris Barrington, managing director at employee communications agency, blue goose – www.bluegoose.co.uk

Chris Barrington

Chris Barrington

There is a false and potentially dangerous assumption, particularly in the financial services sector, that risks can be managed by mandating employees to follow rules, standards and regulations, often solely through compulsory e-learning.

Whilst building robust risk-related processes and oversight structures to better manage risks is key, it is only part of the story. Developing a risk culture, in which the attitudes and behaviours of employees are a first line of defence against Conduct Risk, is just as important.

Yet the compliance-based and directive interventions currently on offer are rarely an effective answer to the challenge of compliance.

In fact, regardless of the compliance issue, so-called ‘learning technology’ is too often the tail that wags the dog and compliance-based, rather than engagement-based interventions, are the norm.

Most of the current organisational effort around compliance appears to be directive, and focused on defending against the regulator and legal liabilities rather than addressing what are in effect the real issues behind the regulation.

Since the Enron scandal in 2000, organisations have been focusing on easy, quick and auditable defences that have spawned an entire industry built around “compliance training”.

However, their style of compliance training mostly focuses on meeting a regulatory requirement or reducing legal liability and real learning or engagement with employees in a relevant and memorable way has become a bonus.

When compliance initiatives are directive they tend to focus on the narrow rules and regulations of the issue at stake and pay little attention to the wider cultural context of the organisation. As such, they tend to reduce the room for discussion and debate about compliance and make a breach more likely.

Furthermore, where compliance-based and directive interventions take hold, breaking out of that mindset and moving beyond the e-learning tick-box mentality is difficult.

As a result compliance has been reduced to a game of beating the system with the least possible effort.  What should and could be a highly engaging exploration of issues that has a very tangible impact, becomes a frustrating chore to be finished as quickly as possible.

Organisations trying to mandate compliance will continue to risk it all. Not only will they be more open to breaches of compliance, but they will be subject to greater financial penalties and reputational damage than those that can demonstrate they have made efforts to truly engage with employees.

There are plenty of studies that show that organisations that communicate effectively with employees are more likely to be successful, but it shouldn’t take a research report to understand the benefits – it just takes common sense. At the very least, organisations should recognise that high quality communication and engagement is important mitigation should something go wrong.

What’s surprising is that HR and learning professionals and their vendors, haven’t done more to make compliance training and interventions more engaging – particularly to shift them away from so-called e-learning.

Ultimately compliance training has done much to damage the credibility of e-learning, and in turn damage the reputation of many organisations.

So what are the key hallmarks of effective compliance communications?

There is often little differentiation between what most organisations say in their compliance communications, whether the topic is their code of conduct, health and safety or information security.

Therefore, effective compliance communications rests on how they communicate around those issues, something that varies significantly.

Combining employee communication, learning and engagement to create a comprehensive integrated campaign focused on behaviour change is key to going beyond simply telling employees to follow rules, standards and guidelines.

The graph below illustrates some of the characteristics of compliance communication at either ends of a compliance/engagement continuum:

compliance diagramOrganisations stuck at the wrong end of the continuum will contribute to a culture that is actually more likely to result in non-compliance and breaches. They will miss the opportunity to drive competitive advantage through risk management and they are quite likely to get the breach they deserve.

Continue Reading

Recent Posts

The lockdown money revolution 29 The lockdown money revolution 30
FINANCE4 days ago

The lockdown money revolution

By Granville Turner, Director at Turner Little. Many Brits have found that lockdown has been beneficial for their money, having...

Self-employed taxpayers and Making Tax Digital 31 Self-employed taxpayers and Making Tax Digital 32
BUSINESS4 days ago

Self-employed taxpayers and Making Tax Digital

By John Hemming, CEO of Cirrostratus Exedra, the company that runs the VAT Direct Making Tax Digital Service The HMRC’s ambition...

Auditor regulation and litigation - down to the Wire(card)? 33 Auditor regulation and litigation - down to the Wire(card)? 34
BANKING5 days ago

Auditor regulation and litigation – down to the Wire(card)?

By Tom Snelling, partner at Signature Litigation and David Entwistle, a regulatory lawyer and legal risk specialist Introduction The collapse...

Why it’s time to adapt to the virtual world: how to master online negotiations 35 Why it’s time to adapt to the virtual world: how to master online negotiations 36
TECHNOLOGY5 days ago

Why it’s time to adapt to the virtual world: how to master online negotiations

By Tony Hughes, CEO at Huthwaite International, a leading global provider of sales, negotiation and communication skills development Virtual negotiations...

Protecting against man in the middle attacks with dynamic linking 37 Protecting against man in the middle attacks with dynamic linking 38
FINANCE2 weeks ago

Protecting against man in the middle attacks with dynamic linking

By David Vergara, Senior Director of Product Marketing at OneSpan In recent years, the booming growth of mobile applications has...

The Case for Banks to Digitally Transform: Iterating out of lockdown 39 The Case for Banks to Digitally Transform: Iterating out of lockdown 40
BANKING2 weeks ago

The Case for Banks to Digitally Transform: Iterating out of lockdown

By Sudeepto Mukherjee, Senior VP, Banking EMEA & APAC, Publicis Sapient. Before COVID-19 disrupted every imaginable part of society, banks...

Difficulties of Getting on the Property Ladder Post-Pandemic 41 Difficulties of Getting on the Property Ladder Post-Pandemic 42
LIFESTYLE2 weeks ago

Difficulties of Getting on the Property Ladder Post-Pandemic

There is a lot of talk about what’s going to happen to the housing market over the next few months....

Russian Doll: Building digital capabilities into a bank’s core 43 Russian Doll: Building digital capabilities into a bank’s core 44
BANKING2 weeks ago

Russian Doll: Building digital capabilities into a bank’s core

By Ian Johnson, Managing Director of Europe, Marqeta COVID-19 has left its mark on every industry, and banking is no...

How the US and Europe's COVID-19 Responses Have Affected Exchange Rates 45 How the US and Europe's COVID-19 Responses Have Affected Exchange Rates 46
TRADING2 weeks ago

How the US and Europe’s COVID-19 Responses Have Affected Exchange Rates

In living memory, few events have thrown the reputations of different countries and regions under such intense scrutiny as the...

Recognising the surprise PE investment potential in southern Africa 47 Recognising the surprise PE investment potential in southern Africa 48
INVESTING2 weeks ago

Recognising the surprise PE investment potential in southern Africa

By Martin Soderberg, partner at SPEAR Capital. An event of historic significance passed largely unnoticed in the world’s media recently,...

Why Banking is experiencing a second wave of transformation 49 Why Banking is experiencing a second wave of transformation 50
BANKING2 weeks ago

Why Banking is experiencing a second wave of transformation

By Keith Pearson, Head of Financial Services EMEA, ServiceNow The financial landscape has seen significant changes in the last six...

Making your mark: an introduction to trademarks 51 Making your mark: an introduction to trademarks 52
TRADING2 weeks ago

Making your mark: an introduction to trademarks

By James Turner, Director at  Turner Little  Are you looking to protect your brand? The chances are, you are –...